Instant Pot Oyster Stew (in 15 Minutes!)
In today’s world, it can be harder than ever to get the nutrition your body needs. Even if you consume a colorful and widely varied diet, today’s soils are severely depleted of nutrients. And that means the foods that come from these soils are nutrient depleted as well.
On top of that, the pollution and stress you face in your daily life taxes your antioxidant defenses and further depletes your body’s stores of nutrients. And don’t forget the winter months, when the sun is low in the sky and vitamin D production is limited.
Nutrient depletion weakens your immunity, hampers your ability to detoxify and increases you risk of chronic disease.
That’s why we are always looking for ways to get the greatest nutritional bang per bite. For example, I often add nutrient-rich heart and liver to meatballs. We buy organic produce, not just to avoid chemicals in our cuisine, but also because struggle makes plants stronger (and more nutrient rich).
Finally, we do our best to include foods that are extremely nutrient dense in our diet. And you might be surprised to learn that…
Love Instant Pot Recipes?
Get Your FREE Instant Pot Paleo Recipes Book Here
Oysters are One of the Most Nutrient Dense Foods on the Planet
Oysters are bivalves – animals that filter nutrients in phytoplankton and then concentrate those nutrients into their meat.
Oysters are especially high in vitamin B12, zinc, and copper. They’re also very rich in omega-3 fats. On an ounce-per-ounce basis, they provide triple the amount of omega-3 fatty acids as you would find in wild salmon!
In fact, the table below shows the power-packed nutrition you’ll find in just one bowl of the Instant Pot Oyster Stew featured at the end of this post. You’ll also see how it stacks up to the nutrients in other foods:
Nutrient | One Serving Oyster Stew | Equivalent Food Source |
Vitamin B12 | 378% | 10 oz. steak |
Zinc | 158% | 7 oz. short ribs |
Selenium | 156% | 7 oz. mackerel |
Copper | 113% | 9 cups of kale |
Vitamin A | 50% | 3.5 oz. tuna |
Manganese | 48% | 3 oz. bass |
Iron | 41% | 5 oz. skirt steak |
Phosphorous | 33% | 4 oz. pork sirloin |
Riboflavin | 29% | 2 hard boiled eggs |
Vitamin C | 23% | 1 cup blueberries |
Omega 3 (EPA/DHA) | 963 mg | 2.5 oz. wild salmon |
Cholesterol (learn about the benefits of cholesterol here) | 249 mg | 5.5 oz shrimp |
Because the nutrient density and contaminant levels of oysters can vary according to the environment where they live, it is very important to choose oysters from a clean source. The brand of oysters we trust is Goose Point Oysters, from the Willapa Bay National Wildlife Refuge. They are rated “eco-best” by the Environmental Defense Fund and come from one of the cleanest estuaries in the US. This brand can be found in many supermarkets nationwide.
In today’s quick and delicious recipe, we turn these gifts from the sea into an immune-boosting stew that you can enjoy all winter long! So, let’s get to the step by step and make some oyster stew!
Instant Pot Oyster Stew: A Creamy, Nutrient-Dense Winter Stew in Minutes
For this recipe, I turned to the Instant Pot Electronic Pressure Cooker – my all-time favorite kitchen tool. I already knew how easily and quickly it turned whole chicken (try my pressure cooker whole chicken) and tough cuts of meat (check out my pressure cooker pot roast) to fork tender, and how fast it cooked up delicate seafood like fish and shrimp.
I had a feeling the low pressure setting on the Instant Pot would be ideal for delicate oysters.
Looking at a variety of traditional oyster stew recipes, I decided on the classic ingredients of heavy cream, butter, shallots, celery and garlic, along with some chicken broth, and of course, clean-sourced Goose Point Oysters (and their liqueur – the liquid that they come in).
Add the butter to the Instant Pot and hit the Sauté button to melt…
Add the shallots, garlic and celery. Cook while stirring for about four minutes…
Now pour in the oysters and their liqueur…
Top with heavy cream and bone broth…
Close and lock the lid. Hit the “Manual” button. Then change pressure to “LOW” and set the time for six minutes…
While your oysters cook, whip up a quick salad or warm some Keto Drop Biscuits, and chop some fresh parsley. Your oyster stew will emerge, golden with perfectly tender oysters. Adjust your seasoning – I added ½ tsp. sea salt and ¼ tsp. white pepper. Then ladle into bowls and top with parsley…
Many people who haven’t tried it think oyster stew will be fishy. It’s not – it’s fresh like the ocean, creamy and deliciously addictive. My little one couldn’t get enough!
You can serve the stew with the oysters whole (which looks beautiful). Or if you prefer, you can snip them up, which will make them a bit easier to eat. However you choose to do it, you’re getting a hefty dose of immune-boosting nutrition in every serving!
If you like oysters, check out my Paleo Fried Oyster recipe for another grain-free riff on this superfood seafood!
Original
Prep Time
5 mins
Cook Time
6 mins
Total Time
11 mins
Servings
4
Ingredients
- 1 pint organic heavy cream (or full fat coconut milk for dairy free)
- 1 cup bone broth
- 1 cup minced celery
- 2 10 oz. jars shucked oysters with liqueur
- 2 Tbsp. grass-fed butter (or coconut oil for dairy free)
- 2 Tbsp. minced shallot
- 2 cloves garlic minced
- ½ tsp. sea salt
- ¼ tsp. white pepper
- 2 Tbsp. fresh parsley, chopped
Instructions
- Add butter, saute shallot, garlic and celery until soft (about 4 minutes) Add the oysters, cream and broth
- Close and lock lid, set to LOW pressure and 6 minutes.
- Do a quick release. Stir in the sea salt and white pepper (to taste).
- Snip the oysters using kitchen shears, if desired. Ladle into bowls, garnish with parsley and serve.
Nutrition & Macronutrient Ratio
Nutrition Information Per Serving (1 Bowl Instant Pot Oyster Stew)
597 calories, 53 g fat, 32 g saturated fat, 15 g monounsaturated fat, 3 g polyunsaturated fat, 613 mg EPA, 350 mg DHA, 249 mg cholesterol, 13 g carbohydrate, 12.5 g net carb, 1 g sugar, 1 g fiber, 17 g protein
Macronutrient Ratio: 80% Fat | 12 % Protein | 8% Carbohydrate
Love Instant Pot Recipes?
Get Your FREE Instant Pot Paleo Recipes Book Here
Suzanne says
Was the Nutrient Information Per batch supposed to be a link? It’s not. Do you buy your oysters in jars? That’s cool. I will have to look for them that way as they are too hard to shuck without cutting your hand.
Kelley Herring says
Hi Suzanne!
Thank you for your comments.
The Nutrient Per Batch is not a link, I’ve posted the nutrition info per serving above. And yes, the Goose Point Oysters are wonderful and come pre-shucked in a bottle – no dangerous knife-wielding required!
Be Well!
Kelley
Kelly says
What grocery stores do you typically find the oysters? I checked my local Whole Foods and Sprouts but didn’t find any. 🙁 I’m in San Jose, CA.
Kelley Herring says
Hi Kelly!
I’m surprised those stores don’t carry Goose Point Oysters since they’re an “eco-best”. We get ours from Smith’s.
Be Well,
Kelley
Toni Faught says
I don’t see a calorie count in your nutrition information. Can you provide it? Thank you
Toni Faught says
I don’t see any calorie count in your nutrition information. Can you provide it? Thank you
Kelley Herring says
Hi Toni,
That was an odd little glitch 🙂 You can see it now along with macro ratio.
Be Well,
Kelley
Chrissie Hereford says
How do you cook this with out ani instant pot?
Kelley Herring says
I haven’t tried it, but there are recipes online for oyster stew in a saucepan.
Anna says
Followed the recipe however the are curdled. Any ideas on what I did wrong? (For next time)
Kelley Herring says
Hi Anna,
Did you use LOW pressure? Did your cream contain any additives?
Paula says
Mine also curdled on low pressure
Kelley Herring says
Hi Paula,
So you used LOW pressure and used dairy cream – and it curdled and spewed?
What IP model do you have? Did you use cream with gums or additives? I’ve made this many times without issue.
Lynda Campbell says
Something went wrong in your recipe. I followed it to the letter. When I did the quick release a good majority of it came out through the vent spewing all over the counter. It was gross! It was very good tasting but runny.
Kelley Herring says
Lynda,
A quick release should never cause the contents of any recipe to spew. There was something amiss in your use of the Instant Pot. Please read your manual.
Kelley
Paula says
Mine also spewed.
Sherri Marini says
Hi Kelley,
Can you make this recipe dairy free?
Thank you.
Sherri Marini
Kelley Herring says
Absolutely, Sherri! Use coconut cream in place of the heavy cream, and a traditional fat (lard, tallow, coconut oil) for the butter.
Andy says
Hi Kelley,
I was very pleased to find this recipe… and here’s a tip for you and your readers. (See Anna’s question above.)
My model of Instant Pot (6 quart IP-LUX V3, purchased 12/14/17) does not include a Pressure button for choosing low or high pressure — like the one in your photo above).
I decided to try it anyway, reducing the cook time to 4 minutes. Unfortunately, the pure organic heavy cream I used curdled a bit. It tasted fine, but not a particularly appetizing look with those little lumps of curdled cream.
I should have realized this might happen. Next time, I’ll wait to add the cream until after quick release, then use the Soup setting to warm it up before serving. I’ll also add another 1/2 cup broth, blended with a tablespoon of arrowroot to thicken while it warms. Corn starch would probably work, too, but I prefer organic arrowroot.
That should provide better results. Hope this is helpful!
Kelley Herring says
Hi Andy,
Thanks so much for your kind message and helpful tips!
I’m thinking the “curdling key” here is the pressure. You mention that your IP does not have HIGH and LOW pressure – so I’m betting the higher pressure setting encouraged the curdling.
Organic arrowroot is great for thickening – and much better than cornstarch – good call!
Thanks again and hope to see your comments again soon!
Kelley
Todd says
Do you use chicken or beef bone broth?
Eileen says
Hi Kelley,
I agree with Andy’s comment. Coconut milk should be added *after* cooking to prevent curdling. I also did a NP for 5 min before the QR to prevent the spewing. I live in the PNW and have easy access to oysters, so this receipt is delightful!
Kelley Herring says
Hi Eileen,
Thank you for your comment!
I haven’t had issues with coconut milk or cream curdling in this recipe, but thanks for sharing your thoughts on this and also the slower release technique!
Be Well,
Kelley
BARBARA says
I always thought that oysters needed low simmering to prevent being tough. Do they actually come out tender ? Also how would I adjust the recipe to make a half recipe using only one jar of oysters?
Kelley Herring says
Hi Barbara,
We loved how the oyster stew turned out in the Instant Pot! The oysters were very tender. Because the Instant Pot cooks this soup at low temperature with low pressure, it is a very gentle setting perfect for delicate seafood.
You can certainly halve the recipe.
Also, some commenters (see messages above) feel adding the cream after cooking the oysters is a better choice. I have not had issues with the cream curdling, but you may want to try that method.
Hope this helps!
Kelley
Paula says
Followed the recipe. Low pressure. No additives. Curdled.
The ingredients are the same that my family has used for decades however I should’ve know the temp would be to high for the delicate ingredients. We have always slowly heated oyster stew in a water bath. Ah well live and learn!
Kelley Herring says
Paula,
Hmm, the maximum temperature in an Instant Pot is 210 F. So, I don’t believe that temperature is the issue in this case. “Low” heat on the stove is around 200 F, also.
Here’s the info on temperatures from Instant Pot:
The 3 temperature ranges in the Instant Pot® are: Less: 82-87.8°C/180-190°F (low setting in a slow cooker) Normal: 87.8~93°C/190-200°F (medium setting in a slow cooker) More: 93~99°C/200~210°F (high setting in a slow cooker)
You are right that higher temperature would make the oysters tough. But you didn’t say they were tough. You said it spewed and curdled.
I’d like to be able to reproduce the issue. Can you please tell me your Instant Pot model?
Kelley
Stephanie says
Hi Kelley!
I’ve looked at this recipe a hundred times; COVID lockdown has had me trying a bunch of new recipes and I finally got to this one. I just wanted to tell you it came out perfect, no curdling no worries, and it tastes amazing! I used a blend of half and half, full fat coconut milk, and almond milk (all organic) just FYI. Thanks for all your recipes!
Emma Brown says
What would make our oyster soup look like it is “clambered”? Is it safe to eat?
Kelley Herring says
Hi Emma,
What kind of cream or coconut product did you use? Did it have any gums in it? As you can see from all of the comments, some people say it comes out great – other people get the curdling.
Reginia Sam says
Made this today and mine came out perfectly. It tastes good and the right amount of salt was added. I had no problems with mine curdling or spewing. The oysters can also be found at Walmart.